Posts

Showing posts from May, 2024

The closing speech and directions to the jury

Image
The closing speech of Luke Mitchell's trial, delivered by Advocate Depute Alan Turnbull on 18th January 2005, provides some insight in to the directions and instructions presented to the jury in regards to the deliberation of their verdict. (Full transcript will be uploaded as soon as possible, along with others - please note, this just part of the closing speech and given as an example) “ I’ll explain to you what evidence the Crown say you ought to accept. I’ll explain to you why you ought to accept that evidence and I’ll explain to you why, if you do accept that evidence , it ought to be returning a verdict of guilty on the murder charge." "Now in undertaking that evidence I’ll necessarily have to examine that evidence, I'll have to discuss it, I’ll have to analyse it, and in doing that of course, I’ll have to rely on my notes that I took at the time, on memory, my own understanding of the evidence. And when I discuss the evidence with you, my intention is t

The Sumi knife

Image
    The Sumi knife (swabbing/blood 68a) A Sumi knife was noted in the productions for the Luke Mitchell case - below is a screen shot that was shared online with items from this list.  Please note that the piece of knife (swab) 199a is from the knife found in the skip and does not belong to the Sumi knife - there is more information on the skip knife h ere: https://www.spa.police.uk/publication-library/foi-2023-24-070-knife-examined-in-luke-mitchell-jody-jones-case/response/?fbclid=IwAR07nU1THoCAIZb5KwdSP8qnYcxFSSFl-3lDcWfPL06XBSUD0H7Wn8_t1uI#publication-paren t                                 Measurements of the Sumi knife according to SPA:                       147mm long (5.7 inches) and 20mm in maximum width (0.78 inches) https://www.spa.police.uk/publication-library/foi-2023-24-090-knife-found-at-home-farm-2003-in-luke-mitchell-jody-jones-case/response/#:~:text=The%20Sumi%20knife%20is%20a,and%2020mm%20in%20maximum%20width. SPA were asked if they could confirm whether the blood on